Wednesday, August 1, 2018

Gable Vent vs other vents


Being a contractor over 20 years, I saw so many homes abused by their owners and they all had one common issue the owner was probably oblivious to.  The attic ventilation. 
When I started in remodeling, it was drummed into our heads to make sure a home had cornice vents to intake cooler air into the attic and gable vents to allow the hot air to escape.  The gable vents needed to be as high as possible on the gable wall to be the most efficient.  Attic insulation was placed into the ceiling below to create a heat and cold barrier for the living space below. 
Now, there are so many other products in play for the top slot of the best ventilation.  Turbines or whirley birds are produced by GAF, Air Vent and many more.  The issue I have found with these are they only vent 19 square inches each.  If you calculate the average attic space to ventilation, the roof would be covered with roof turbines to allow enough hot hair to escape and be effective.  Flat vents or pan roof vents seem to have a bigger issue as they actually trap the hot air before releasing it if there is no airflow in the space. 
Some people add power attic fans to force the hot air out.  This is a sound idea with the fan being turned on and off by the temperature of the attic.  Dayton produces many different sizes and styles that will properly cool your attic.  The only issue with this is usually the installation.  If the install is too close to the exterior of the home, excess moisture builds and causes damage to the units.  Then the issue of over heating and causing an attic fire usually due to improper wiring. 
In a lot of cases, the product you choose from any manufacturer failing is not the fault of the manufacturer, but the installer with a lack of knowledge of proper installation.
Most of the new homes being built have their cornice vents eliminated.  Now there is no cool air intake for the attic to push the hot air out.  Tamko offers a vinyl ridge vent.  This product usually activates on it’s own at about 120 degrees to allow the hot air to escape.  I have rarely been in an attic with ridge vent that was over 130 degrees.  First, the installer will cut a strip off the roof peak to create a vent hole.  Being applied at the peak of the roof it is in direct contact with the hottest air.  To protect the vinyl ridge vent from the damage of the sun, it is covered with shingles.  Issues I have found with ridge vent is the slight rippling of the vinyl over heating and powder snow drift getting into the attic by drifting through the small vents.  Some installers like to sell a mesh to put under the vent to prevent snow entering.  This quickly fills with dust and no longer allows the attic to breath.
No matter the attic vent you choose, you should enter your attic each year to check that vents are clear of packing boxes, dust and even blown insulation that may have drifted onto them. 
Proper ventilation ensures many extra years on your roof and keeps your homes walls from sweating and damaging the home’s structure. 
After all I have seen, I see the best attic ventilation for me is to go old style.  I like the cornice vents found at any hardware store like Lowe’s and Home Depot.  They are cheap and can be placed every 3 foot around the home under the overhang. 
My preferred gable vent is not wood since it rots.  I am not fond of galvanized as they rust.  I do not like maintaining products by painting them.  So, vinyl vents?  Heat tends to warp and cause the louvers to droop cutting off the ventilation. 
Aluminum seems to be the current best vent material.  But then you have to choose a manufacturer that makes a quality vent.  Some manufacturers use wood in their vent frames.  Some even use rusty staples to hold their vents together.  My choice is Onyx Xteriors gable vents.  They use all aluminum frames and pop rivets.  I even like the extra stiffness of the rail system they use.  And I do not have to paint them to match.  And Onyx Xteriors will make the vents the size I need.  I hate having to cut a larger hole or trying to trim it out when the vent is too small.
To check the airflow in your attic, you can place a thermometer in your attic and check it at the hottest time of day.  If the temp is over 130, you may need a pro to come check your attic and vents.  You can also check your attic insulation if your second floor rooms are getting too hot.  Overheating of second floor rooms causes walls to sweat and shift.  In some cases, even buckle or waver.  I like the pre bagged Pink Panther insulation as it is easy to install and self contained.
Needless to say, with all these years of watching happy and sad homes, and all this technology to upgrade an attic, I still lean to the old way of gable end vents and cornice vents for a natural, no maintenance attic vent. 
The newest thing I have seen on the market is the roof edge vent.  It applies where the drip edge would go under the edge of the shingles.  It can be applied anywhere on the roof.  Problem, how often do you clean your gutters of pine straw and leaves? 
If you see a new product on the market for venting, please let me know.

ref:
shop.onyxxteriors.com
#onyxvents

No comments:

Post a Comment